Amy had been a staff nurse in the same hospital for 30 years. Her shift starts with making rounds in different 15 wards and ensuring they follow all the patient safety protocols.
One day she found water on the Ward No. 3 floor due to the cleaning staff’s negligence. Despite noticing this issue, she keeps on moving with her job.
Her reasons to not report the problem were:
- – Reporting meant lots of paperwork
- – Reporting could put her hours behind schedule
- – She had to waste time on hearing back from the admin department
- – Importantly, she doesn’t want to cause any trouble to the poor cleaning staff
So, she didn’t report at that time, and the issue remained unresolved. After a few days, some patients fall from the wet floor in the ward. Now patient falls are serious. And it doesn’t look good if the investigation reveals negligence. So, they go unreported as well!
The result? The hospital continues to score poor safety results. The reason for not reporting could be credible or just laziness. Under-reporting doesn’t help the organization meet its safety goals. The story above is not an isolated story of anyone hospital or nurse.
Statistics tell us that this seems to be the norm:
- – Almost 25% of incidents go unreported. (Source: Sentis)
- – Around 100 errors go unreported while recording. (Source: Pharmacy Times)
- – Every year about 7,150 deaths occurred due to not reporting incidents in hospitals.(Source: Yale News)
- – The Journal of Patient Safety]] suggested in 2013 that 440,000 people per year die from preventable medical errors. (Source: Medscape)
Even though we have data indicating under-reporting in hospitals, not many practitioners follow the proper reporting process. QUASR tries to address this issue with simple tools that seek to address common reasons for under-reporting. Let us first understand Under-reporting and its Reasons.
What is Under-reporting?
Under-reporting means an issue, incident, or the fact that an individual or organization has not reported. Under-reporting is a failure in data gathering.
In hospitals, sometimes individual staff hide or don’t report some incidents. However, unfortunately, it is not possible to know ahead of time how these under-reported incidents affect long-term patient safety.
Recently a study published in the Stanford Business on how hospitals acquired infections is reported in Medicare claims. Researchers found that hospitals with lighter reporting requirements were more miscoded by examining hundreds of Medicare patients, as hospital-acquired infections(HAIs) were presented on admission (POAs). 18.5% of infections said to present upon admission were acquired in the hospital.
Overall, under-reporting is a critical issue that should be analyzed and treated by the hospitals on priority.
4 Reasons Behind Under-reporting in Hospitals
There are plenty of different reasons that generate under-reporting problems in hospitals worldwide. Some of the common underreporting causes in hospitals are:
Fear of Repercussion
One of the most common reasons why an incident goes unreported is a fear of repercussion. We don’t think there are any organizations in today’s day and age where an employee is penalized for taking the initiative.
Still, many staff that we have met on and off have mentioned that they are afraid it will reflect poorly on them if they reported an issue. Organizations may have to do more to ensure that an incident is not a reflection of the staff. From our discussions with our clients, this is often amongst the top few reasons why incidents go unreported.
No Time To Report
Staff on the floor are amongst the busiest people we meet on a given day. Incident reporting in such a dynamic is quite tricky. Most incident forms are lengthy and require the staff to write up in sufficient detail, then participate in multiple investigation sessions to complete the incident report.
Often incident reports have to be filed within a predetermined number of hours since the incident occurred. If they cannot do this, they usually forget and don’t get around to filing the same. It is especially true for incidents that don’t cause any harm to the patients as such since everyone’s priority is patient safety and care.
Hospital staff often do not have time, and hence they may tend to ignore incidents that they believe are not serious enough. Lack of time is also one of the top reasons why under-reporting occurs, based on our discussions with our clients.
Lack of Transparency
Often the reporting person is wholly left out of the incident processing loop. Many organizations have a perfect reason to do this for some types of incidents too. But some processes are not designed to be transparent at all. The process leaves many people out, and they don’t understand how their reporting an incident helped the organization or patient benefit. This can also lead the staff to believe that their incident report went into some “filing black hole”, and no one even had a chance to process their report.
It is possible to revise the incident process to be more transparent when it is digitalized. A digital system allows for frequent and early feedback to all the stakeholders. By being transparent, the system becomes more inclusive of all staff and helps them realize the value of their contribution.
Insufficient Trainin or Knowledge
Many healthcare institutions are unaware of the fact that their incident reporting system isn’t transparent. Not many hospital staff members know when, how and whom to report. The lack of reporting knowledge occurs due to poor communication.
Most hospitals would share this information with their new workers during the orientation and training process. But learning occurs differently to different people. Often, a single knowledge sharing session is insufficient to orient all the users in the processes.
Additionally, organizations share critical information via email. Frontline workers like nurses or ward attendants don’t have regular access to a computer to receive information on time.
The only way to address this is continuous training or frequent sessions to help the staff get oriented to new systems better. The other often ignored method is to build intuitive systems.
How does QUASR help you address under-reporting
QUASR has a suite of nifty tools integrated into the system to help address under-reporting. For instance, to specifically address the fear of repercussions, QUASR uses a novel pseudo-anonymous reporting that allows users to hide their identity at the time of reporting. We do this so that the users will feel safe reporting, but at the same time, the Quality Managers don’t have to deal with insufficient data for investigation later on.
Similarly, we use a multi-stage questionnaire for collecting the details with the ability to resume your data at any step. This allows staff to fill in the incident report over multiple breaks without blocking off a significant portion of their time to do this.
QUASR, at its core, believes that an incident management system is an essential knowledge repository for the healthcare organization to learn from and disseminate information over. So transparency is one of the critical considerations of the design with suitable mechanisms to protect sensitive data when the need arises.
Finally, QUASR aims to keep the application simple in appearance and manner. The bottom line consideration for every element added into QUASR is the amount of training each user would need to use that element effectively. We have designed the user interface in line with some of the social applications familiar to us. This allows us, the users, to quickly adopt and start using QUASR with minimal training efforts.
We will be covering some of these features like pseudo-anonymity or sensitive incidents in individual blog posts in the future. So do watch this blog for more information.
Meanwhile, feel free to contact us or drop us a note if you need further information on any of these topics in particular or QUASR in general!